Gospel Decoded
HomeAll entries › Haggai

“A bag pierced through”

Haggai 1:6
Figure of speechSettledThe LORD
You earn wages to put into a bag pierced through. (Haggai 1:6 BSB)
* An idiom for money that vanishes as fast as it is earned: wages dropped into a purse full of holes leak away and leave you with nothing, whether through inflation, waste, or God's withholding of blessing.

What it sounds like today

A literal note about happening to use a torn money-bag.

The cultural key

The image is a vivid picture of economic futility. In a coin economy, people carried their silver in a cloth or leather purse tied at the belt; a purse 'pierced through' with holes lets the coins slip out and scatter as you walk, so that you reach the market with an empty bag. Haggai uses it to describe a people whose labor never seems to get ahead: they plant much and harvest little, eat but are never full, earn wages that somehow evaporate, because, the prophet says, they have neglected God's house while paneling their own, and God has withdrawn His blessing from their toil. 'Wages into a bag with holes' becomes a proverb for effort that yields nothing, income devoured by inflation, waste, or unseen loss. A modern reader pictures a torn wallet; the point is the maddening experience of working hard and watching it all leak away.

Recovered meaning

'A bag pierced through' is an idiom for wages that vanish as fast as they are earned, leaking away to leave you with nothing. Haggai blames a people who neglected God's house while their own labor mysteriously came to nothing.

Parallels: Haggai 1:9; Haggai 2:16
Part of Gospel Decoded, 833 phrases from across the whole Bible decoded into their first-century meaning. Open this entry in the interactive explorer →
Browse all 833 entries →