Gospel Decoded
HomeAll entries › Isaiah

“Justice, but saw bloodshed”

Isaiah 5:7
Foreign wordSettledIsaiah
He looked for justice, but saw bloodshed; for righteousness, but heard a cry of distress. (Isaiah 5:7 BSB)
* Two bitter Hebrew puns close the Song of the Vineyard: God looked for mishpat (justice) but found mispach (bloodshed), for tsedaqah (righteousness) but heard tse'aqah (a cry). The near-identical words make the perversion of justice audible.

What it sounds like today

A plain statement that God wanted good but found evil.

The cultural key

The verse ends the Song of the Vineyard with a devastating double pun that only works in Hebrew. God looked for mishpat, 'justice,' but found mispach, 'bloodshed', two words that sound almost identical, a single letter apart. Then He looked for tsedaqah, 'righteousness,' but heard tse'aqah, 'a cry' (the scream of the oppressed), again nearly the same sound. The wordplay is the point: what God planted looked, from a distance, almost right, the words are close enough to be mistaken for each other, but on inspection the good word has curdled into its ugly near-twin. Justice slid into bloodshed, righteousness into screaming. English can only footnote the puns, but they turn a general complaint into a precise, chilling portrait of a society that kept the sound of virtue while losing its substance.

Recovered meaning

The line hides two Hebrew puns, justice (mishpat) soured into bloodshed (mispach), righteousness (tsedaqah) into a cry (tse'aqah), near-identical words a hair apart. The sound-alikes show a society that kept virtue's appearance while its substance rotted.

Parallels: Isaiah 5:1–2; Micah 2:2
Part of Gospel Decoded, 833 phrases from across the whole Bible decoded into their first-century meaning. Open this entry in the interactive explorer →
Browse all 833 entries →